Score: 10

"beautifully cinemeatic"

submission: Ultra Sheriff - Nemesis

date: May 31, 2009

This was amazing, it's awesome to see such a great quality of traditional animation on newgrounds. The limited colour schemes and controlled use of effects made the fluid motion so fun to watch.

i can't get over how well planned out your shots were. Some shots, while seeming like there wasn't actually much happening in the shot (purely from an animators perspective), felt very emmersive.

I think that more explanation of a story, and less of the music video look and feel would really help to make it more epic, as story elements could gradually build to a climax.

Work like this is very underrated on Newgrounds, so it's good to see it climbing the ranks.

Score: 9

"very nice"

submission: bluh bluh bluh.

date: May 19, 2009

Cute, cool little animation. I like this simplicity, though can appreciate how long this sort of work takes (especially with plasticine getting all underneath your fingernails :) )

You might want to De-interlace your video footage. This would stop all those lines from appearing whenever there's motion. It was a little bit distracting

Nice work, :)

Score: 3

"pretty low, guys"

submission: Brawl Funnies [Dick 1]

date: May 11, 2009

I'm not really a fan of their work myself, but I thought attacking these people in this way was really low. i wouldn't have minded if it was more satirical in nature, but this was so hate filled it really dragged down the very few interesting shorts. You could have taken something that annoyed you about Newgrounds and created something really true and clever, but it just feels so childish.

Newgrounds desperately needs some new content besides the usual video game parody/anime animation, and this isn't adding anything new.

I thought the Flash submission agreement said that content shouldn't be hateful to groups or people? Someone should have drawn the line here, especially when it comes to groups inciting hatred to the sites own members.